NUJ submits legal challenge to government's lockdown support measures

  • 22 Jul 2020

The legal action marks a significant acceleration in the union's campaign to secure equal treatment for freelance workers.

The NUJ has submitted a legal challenge to the UK government claiming that the Self Employment Income Support Scheme (SEISS) introduced by the Treasury has excluded large numbers of freelance workers and is therefore discriminatory. The legal action marks a significant acceleration in the union's campaign to secure equal treatment for freelance workers.

The NUJ also contends that the Treasury has failed to produce a coherent policy to explain the circumstances (if any) in which those working for publicly-funded employers can access support via the Coronavirus Job Retention Scheme (CJRS).

Michelle Stanistreet, NUJ general secretary, said:

"The NUJ has campaigned hard to persuade the government to do the right thing and support freelances who have not been allowed to access government support during this unprecedented health crisis. Sadly, that hasn't happened and many NUJ freelances have experienced enormous hardship.
"We're taking this legal step because it is clearly wrong and grossly unfair that some workers have been given vital support whilst others have been cast adrift. Even at this late stage our hope remains that the government will rethink and take urgent measures to right this wrong.
"This crisis should act as a wake-up call about the working practices for journalists, and other freelances in the creative industries. We need reformed public policy for freelances and the self-employed that is fit for purpose and reflects the way in which workers are forced to operate by employers."

In a pre-action protocol letter sent by the union to the Treasury this week, the NUJ argues that the SEISS is unlawful on a number of grounds including that it is discriminatory and irrational - the scheme violates the European Convention on Human Rights if Article 14 is taken in conjunction with Article 1 of the Protocol No.1.

Both the income support (SEISS) and the job retention (CJRS) schemes were designed to help employed and self-employed workers. They formed part of a package of measures which the chancellor presented as "doing whatever it takes" to help those affected economically by the pandemic, however the government has excluded PAYE freelancers from the SEISS scheme and often has also excluded them from the CJRS scheme. This means the chancellor has failed to protect a significant number of working people whose incomes were affected in precisely the same way as others who have qualified for assistance.

In light of the substantial and ongoing hardship faced by NUJ freelance members, the union is now seeking an urgent review and revision of the SEISS Direction and/or the CJRS Direction. The union aims to secure amendments to the schemes and ensure they are more accessible to all PAYE freelance workers.

A response to the claim has been requested by 27 July 2020 and if no satisfactory response is received then the NUJ will consider commencing judicial review proceedings.

Since the imposition of the lockdown in March 2020, the NUJ has been lobbying the UK government to provide adequate support and assistance for all media workers, as part of this work the Federation of Entertainment Unions (FEU) launched a campaign for the 'Forgotten Freelances'.

#Forgotten Freelances news

PA Media.png
NUJ's campaign for recognition at PA moves to next stage

Central Arbitration Committee makes decision

19 April 2024
Lyra McKee.jpg
Fifth anniversary of the death of journalist Lyra McKee marked by the NUJ

"Her killing deprived us of a brave and challenging voice" says NUJ Irish secretary

18 April 2024
michele vincent.jpeg 1
Tributes paid to former Rotherham Advertiser reporter and NUJ South Yorkshire Branch secretary Michele Vincent

"Kind and caring" Vincent was branch secretary for two decades

17 April 2024
Keep BBC Local Radio Local.jpg
Concerns raised by Public Accounts Committee about impact of BBC Local Radio cuts

Report on BBC's Across the UK programme criticises corporation

17 April 2024

Return to listing