NUJ statement on Milburn Report
The NUJ has warned that proposals to cut disability support benefits for people under the age of 25 must be rejected.
The Milburn Report proposes to make disabled people under 25 ineligible for Personal Independence Payment (PIP) and the Universal Credit Health element, and to replace these with a Youth Allowance benefit that is temporary, conditional and subject to sanctions.
The only unconditional benefit for under 25s would be the "Severe and Complex Needs Insurance" limited to those "whose profound and enduring disability means they will never be able to work or participate."
This simplistic view fails to recognise the complex and dynamic nature of disability, including fluctuating and episodic conditions and changes over time, as recognised under the Equality Act 2010. It also fails to uphold the rights of all disabled people to independence and dignity.
Natasha Hirst, NUJ Disabled Members’ rep, said:
“We are deeply concerned that the Milburn Review is targeting young disabled people as a means to cutting welfare costs. Young disabled people deserve financial security and full access to their rights; it is not possible to engage with education or employment if additional disability-related costs of living are not met.
"We welcome the Milburn report's support for engaging young people in study and work and the recognition of the importance of preventative health and timely and adequate provision of healthcare. However, we warn against arbitrary cuts to disability benefits and against sanctions, which are counterproductive and harmful for young disabled people. We urge our members to scrutinise these proposals carefully and seek out the voices of young disabled people who would be affected, to inform your reporting.”
The proposals raise concerns about age discrimination and suggestions that the same regime should be extended to people of all ages causes further urgent concern about disability discrimination. These proposals risk removing support that enables disabled people to participate in society, including in work. Potential harmful consequences include endangering employment.
Disabled journalists, often in precarious and low paid roles, are enabled by disability benefits and passported support to study and work. Withdrawing this support will be a barrier to work and will reduce representation of disabled people in journalism and media roles.
Ample evidence, including from the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP)'s own trials, shows that welfare sanctions do not result in engaging disabled people with work. There is also significant evidence of harm, including deaths of disabled people, as a result of the sanctions regime, with dozens of cases from the past two years currently under investigation by the DWP.
The report also fails to recognise the need for preventative health in education settings, and the ongoing health impact of Covid which since 2019 has created a new cohort of disabled young people, including disabled young journalists. The TUC’s recent analysis on the disability pay gap, highlights that disabled workers are more likely to be in part-time, freelance and insecure work, and face significantly lower incomes, while also managing disproportionately high costs of disability.
The NUJ’s Disabled Members’ Council reminds members to avoid harmful and misinforming media coverage that fails to represent disabled voices and recognise disabled people's rights. We urge responsible reporting and fact checking and encourage members to attend our upcoming webinar, ‘Reporting on disability issues accurately’, on 25 November from 5pm to 6.15pm.
References:
- From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation, DWP, 17 November 2026
- Disability pay gap means disabled workers effectively stop earning from today, TUC, 16 November 2026
On the shortcomings of local disability employment support:
- Work and Pensions Committee, 23 June 2026
On conditionality and sanctions:
- Serious questions over DWP pilot scheme at heart of ministers’ jobs strategy, Disability News Service, 28 May 2026
- DWP admits 50 secret investigations into claimant deaths led to calls for improvements last year, Disability News Service, 3 September 2026
- Terms of engagement: Rethinking conditionality to support more people into better jobs, New Economics Foundation, 23 July 2024
- Social Security System "sanctions and demonises Disabled People" - DR UK responds to Employment Inquiry, Disability Rights UK, 8 April 2024
- Benefit cuts won’t solve fundamental problems with jobs market: The New Economics Foundation, 17 November 2026